ArticlesBlog

The shocking amount of sugar hiding in your food – BBC

The shocking amount of sugar hiding in your food  – BBC


Dietician Allison bones wants to show a group of office workers Just how much energy in the form of sugar these carbs release into their bloodstream Foods we’ve got there you go and a chocolate muffin Hey, I would say that that is more sugar than this one. Maybe two cubes for that one We’re calling this blood sugar bingo quell our volunteers Guess the equivalent cubes of sugar in each of these foods. What do you think? Five two minutes got let’s go five. Okay, so you’ve gone for the the muffin as the slightly higher one I’m just gonna add to that So ten sugar cubes and that muffin this one so you’ve gone to two so it’s more starchy less sugary Yeah, let’s just add this one Oh what well maybe not More sugar, there’s eleven sugar cube In this bagel. I’m shocked. I won’t lie. I’m shocked. Yeah what you’re saying Is that in the bagel when you eat it you chew it up and start to digest it Your body is breaking that starch down into that quantity of sugar. Yes, privileged sugar. Yeah. Yeah exactly This is a portion of white rice and then you’ve got nice bowl of strawberries, right? Yes Let’s go for five Never approach ago was right Strawberries I would half of that Bowl They are sweet Okay, so in this amount of strawberries there is Four sugar cubes Oh, yeah, so we’ll only taste sweet Actually, the amount of carbohydrate that they contain is is quite small So let’s compare that to this portion of rice then so you’ve gone for face. Oh, Really it’s grains of sugar that we know more that is that’s just when you should the cube equivalents Jacket potato. Yes. Can you not do that as my favorite food potato? I would go with similar to the bagel. Yeah, like about ten. You’ve got quite a good poker face Allison There’s 19 sugar cubes and in this jacket potatoes almost almost double what you something I’m so sorry. How do Where they hide in order sugar I think one of it one of the key things to take away from this is that looks can be deceiving So just because a food doesn’t necessarily taste sweet Doesn’t mean that there’s not gonna be sometimes an awful lot of sugar going into your system after you’ve eaten it the thing that this really Rams home for me is that there was a huge amount of energy in a potato and that pile of glucose there that will your body will turn the potato into Will be stored as fat unless you burn it off unless you have to be careful about what you’re putting in your mouth

Comments (100)

  1. The bagel may have more carbs in it but surely its better for you than a chocolate muffin?! The potato has important vitamins and minerals and things that are good for you as well. Silly test imo.

  2. What a stupid video! Carbs are good, you can not live without carbs. They give us the energy we neede throughout the day. Anj just for reference, 100 grams of white rice contains around 30 grams of carbs of which sugar 0,1 grams, definitely not as much sugar they shown in the video. So this is just a completely stupid video.

  3. I am absolutely sure to say that rice, strawberry or any other naturally occurring food is not unhealthy.

  4. Don't spread fake news

  5. Holy shit! That woman was a nutritionist?
    She needs to give better advice.

  6. The entire video takes into account only the convertibility of carbs into sugar. Carbs have so many other functions in your body including your hormone functions. After all these fun tions are carried out only the excess carb is stored as fat. This is a highly misleading video. Carbs are absolutely necessary for the body and should be taken in the right quantity. Natural carbs are not like processed carbs. It is wrong to put rice and potato in the same league as muffin and beagle.

  7. Bull crap. Sucralose does not induce the same insulin response withe fruits vegetables and grains. Absolutely BS

  8. The biggest bullshit of 2018

  9. Anything processed, I would stay away from it much as possible. Eat little enough to survive and have 5 times a day if you feel hungry. Do lot of walking and Yoga is best for healthy life. Life is to short, so enjoy.

  10. Plain IDIOTS for spreading wrong information, BBC should just pull this down immediately.

  11. This is a bit bullshit . Everything has a sugar level . Really depends what quality the food is . Eating potatoes is fine eating rice is fine . Pouring shit manufactured butter will kill you eventually .

  12. Real foods like potatoes, sweet potatoes bread, pasta, rice and fruits are not bad for you!
    All carbs are not the same!

  13. This is a fucking joke. Soon enough theyll be saying McDonalds is bad for your health…

  14. Wow this makes me so glad I'm Paleo! No wonder it's worked best for me keeping weight off . It's so easy to keep to also. I've been one for 8 months and know people who've done it for years 🙂

  15. not all carbohydrates in all these foods are the same and not all equivalent to refined white sugar, where did she go to school??? the body converts all fuel into blood glucose. whole foods have fiber, nutrients and antioxidants, this erroneous comparison of fruit to bagels to refined sugar is criminal. she doesn't speak of ADDED sugar, omg what bad bad information. probably promotes some idiotic paleo diet because she's a flippin idiot

  16. Wtf what are we supposed to eat low carb keto sucks 90% of food is carbs

  17. Most things the BBC does are simplified to such an extent in order to push their political agenda, the BBC is a state broadcaster that pushes itself as impartial when most people have come to realise it is anything but.

  18. Carbs also turns into glucose inside the body.

  19. This is stupid. White rice is quite healthy. Most of Asia survives on rice at least for one meal. And till a couple of decades ago, there were hardly any dietary/ lifestyle diseases in Asia

  20. Full of lies! and lies and lies. Sugar contents in that food are different from sugar we bought at the grocery stores. 🤔

  21. I am eating tons of rice in a day– I don't have diabetes… They should explain that there's adifference between processed sugar and natural glucose effect when you take it in your body.. THis is misleading somehow

  22. This is a ridiculously flawed and irrelevant comparison. There are many other factors that affect your digestion of foods and sugars, most importantly, DIATERY FIER. It "blacks" up to 80% of your sugar consumed from being digested. Also the Japanese are one of the thinnest people get they eat a lot of rice…. Maybe they should switch to chocolate muffins instead? Lol dumb propagandist video that doesn't educate, it only confuses people

  23. She's so under carbed her hand is shaking.

  24. I just need to make this clear that glucose, sucrose, fructose and amylum or starch are all very different and all go through different processes to be broken down by the body. Glucose is a monosaccharide and isn't broken down any further by the body and it's utilised by the by means of insulin which opens up the cells to take it in and whatever is left is stored as muscul glycogen or liver glycogen and if that glycogen isn't used up in time for your next meal and you have enough in store then it goes in to the adipose tissue (fat), fructose is a different case it's a sweet monosaccharide that needs to go through a longer process to be broken down fructose turns in to fat right from the beginning and is usually stored around the liver giving a non alcoholic fatty liver and will need the help of beta hydroxybutyrate (ketones) to back down the fat it also is the reason for low GI foods having a slower spike in insulin production, now sucrose is the combination of the 2 sugars I just mentioned and start braking down when they come in contact with the enzymes called sucrase or asomaltase and return to their former state wich means that they the glucose part will spike the insulin production the fastest all the while opening up the adipose tissue for the fructose but this sucrose (in theory) wouldn't spike the blood sugar as much as starch in the same amount due it having fructose in it unlike starch with is a long brand glucose structure so what I'm saying is that's not quite equal eating 20 sugar cubes wouldn't results in a higher blood glucose mmol/l like a potato would because one is converted in to pure glucose and one is converted in to 2 separate monosaccharides one of which is a low GI carbohydrates that isn't process and utilised in the same way

  25. They should have at least put the same mass of each food type on the table so that comparison would be simpler. Also, they might have indicated how quickly each food broke down into sugars – if the food breaks down very quickly (generally seen as a bad thing), then show the sugar cubes are in one clump, if the food breaks down slowly, put the cubes in a stretched-out line.

  26. This is bullshit.
    Only sugar you should be worried about is sugar not from food.

  27. REAL NEWS HEADLINES
    There are no "Rebels" Syria is not in a civil war. It is a mercenary army armed and financed by the U.S. – U.K. – FRENCH – TURKS – NATO/SAUDIS and ISRAEL in violation of international law.
    The same cabal of evil that attacked and destroyed Libya.

  28. This is the worst analogy I have ever seen in my life !!

  29. Dont forget to minus fibre carbohydrate from fruits

  30. This is BS. The amount of rice I eat, I would turn into an elephant by now. BBC, respect real science.

  31. Shaky hands=low sugar in blood

  32. Drawing an equivalency between rice/potatoes and chocolate muffins/sugar cubes is reductive, overly simplistic and highly misleading. This is just plain bad journalism.

  33. This video is irresponsible. Fruit and starches are some of the healthiest foods. No wonder why people struggle to lose weight with misleading information like this.

  34. omg this is ridiculous

  35. #notallcarbsareequal

  36. Stupidity at it's best 👌

  37. WHAT AM I MEANT TO EAT BBC

  38. So am I supposed to eat air from now? Someone help

  39. There's different types of sugars dummies. Those are sucrose cubes. Fruits have fructose.

  40. For god sake so what can’t we eat now?

  41. As long as it's not added sugar, and you eat a balanced diet you're good.

  42. really doubt the accuracy.

  43. Every one is an exert here.

  44. I don't think the participants understand that they should estimate how much suger the starch break it's also not chemically right to show it like this since sucrose is one part glucose and one part fructose were as starch is chained clucose . The muffin has alot of sucrose and alot of starch while the rice primarily contains starch. Some research show that sucrose is bad in high amounts like the Muffin.

    Also the strawberrys had the least, that so surprising considering they have no water.

  45. "That amount of sugar will turn into fat unless you burn it off." Okay dude, you need a huge amount of energy just to survive through the day. Your brain needs a lot of energy, I read somewhere that it can be about 20% from all the energy that goes into your body. Not to even mention energy our muscles need, respiratory system… nothing is perpetuum mobile so we need that start base. After all, potatoes saved many countries from famine. Better eat da potato, yo.

  46. There’s a difference between complex and simple sugars. Also white/ brown rice along with other processed food. And the amount of carbs that are turned into fats is actually very minor and wouldn’t take place unless you’re in a large calorie surplus

  47. I stop eatting , only drinking raw water ! Yah !

  48. This is simply not true. Humans can only turn about 20% of the calories from starch into fat. The rest is used for energy.

  49. F… you! Just drink water and eat your own clothes.

  50. Too simplified and misleading.

  51. Worst video EVER!!

  52. Wtf misleading title. They're talking about carbs

  53. Sucrose is compromised out of glucose and fructose. The latter poses a far greater danger than the former. Starch cant be converted into fructose. Fructose out of fruit will reach the liver not so fast because your stomach has to extract it from the fiber. This short piece I watched here was nether helpful nor educational in these pivotal matters

  54. Bullshit science at its best…

  55. Judging by most of the ill informed comments below, you are all living in some kind of wonderland, hoping you can eat as many carbs as you like with out getting fat!! It is simple – CARBS = SUGAR = GLUCOSE and EXCESS GLUCOSE = EXCESS ENERGY =FAT, eating too many CARBS makes you FAT if you do not burn it off, eventually leading to diabetes. The point of the video is that 1/3 of a potato turns to GLUCOSE when consumed and is visually illustrated by its equivalent carb value in sugar cubes (each cube = 3 gms of CARBS).

  56. Rice contains 0.1 grams of sugar per 100 grams, while potatoes contain 0.8 grams of sugar per 100 grams. This lady compared the calorie count to cubes of sugar, which is a very different story all together. This video is very misleading.

  57. Go eat cow shit or something

  58. Something doesn't even taste sweet, but contains tons of sugar. What kind of evil is that?

  59. This is just untrue. Please, BBC, get informed and don't fool people. The number of calories is not tantamount to processed sugar. According to this video, it'd be healthier to eat bagels or muffins rather than real food such as potatoes or rice. Calories are not sugar, let alone processed sugar, which is really harmful for your health.

  60. Now everyone thinks muffins are better than rice. Bull horse shit combined information…..

    Forgot to mention the vitamins, minerals and protein and effect of each product on the body.

  61. I think she is stupid lady

  62. I eat rice twice a day everyday. Iam Asian and iam ripped.

  63. This is ridiculous, how unfortunate for people that don’t have other information to believe this. All of Asia lives on rice three times a day at least. Do you want to break down billions of people’s life line and food and compare it to some different sugar based upon carbohydrates? It just doesn’t make sense.

  64. Miss informed video, how can this even allowed to be on. Wish i was there as i would have grilled the so called expert

  65. Do the bbc not understand that a lot of people who watch this now think that choosing chocolate muffins and bagels over rice and potatoes is the healthier option. Terrible video ‘Nutritionist’ lol

  66. The BBC are pumping out anti whole foods propaganda bullshit because they are part of the frigging system that wants people sick

  67. Natural sugar versus processed sugar..big difference

  68. it would have been nice to see all the foods

  69. Come on. This isn't news. I'll still eat loads of (brown) rice and other whole, minimally processed carbs. Eat less often, far more naturally, very low on the food chain, and move a lot more. At least that's my game plan. So far it's working. Of course, I'm only in my 20's…

  70. That's right you can get fat by eating potatoes. Great work BBC keep making people eat the Atkins diet or some shit.

  71. I call bollocks. I can’t imagine a doctor telling you to not eat or cut down on your fruit intake. How many monkeys do you see with diabetes or falling out of trees? From eating to much fruit, with all that sugar. My take on bad ingredients is. If the ingredients list is as long as your arm. It probably ain’t that good for you. Also look in the supermarket. Tesco, Morrisons, Aldi. Majority of the good food is on the perimeter of the shop floor. Because I am useless at explaining stuff. I copied and pasted this.
    How they’re the same: No matter what form sugar comes in, it’s a simple carbohydrate that is broken down for energy. The sugar that’s in a piece of fruit is made up of fructose and glucose, just like processed sugar. Most fruits are 40-55% fructose (although this varies depending on the fruit—cranberries have 20% fructose and apples are 65% fructose). Table sugar is 50% fructose and 50% glucose. Your body processes fructose in the liver so it won’t trigger an insulin response, while glucose starts to break in the stomach and requires insulin to be released into the bloodstream so it can be metabolized quickly. Neither glucose nor fructose is better than the other, when looked at alone. It’s how it’s packaged that makes the difference.

    How they’re different: The type of sugar (natural or refined) that you’re eating impacts your health differently. Natural sugar—the sugar that comes in fruit—is packaged with fiber, water, antioxidants, vitamins, minerals and disease-fighting phtytonutrients and other nutrients that improve your health. (Natural sugar is also found in milk and cheese and is called lactose.) Refined sugar comes from sugar cane or sugar beets, which are both processed to extract the sugar. Usually, this sugar is a combination of glucose and fructose, called sucrose.

    Manufacturers add chemically produced sugar, typically high fructose corn syrup, to many foods and drinks. Other than providing a source of energy that the body can use, processed sugar doesn’t provide any benefits to the body—it lacks the fiber and health-promoting nutrients that occur in natural sugar sources. By contrast, processed sugar can harm the body when overeaten and may contribute to inflammation, disease, weight gain and obesity. This is why refined sugar is known as “empty calories”—calories without nutrients that benefit the body.

    Is there a difference in how you feel after you eat natural sugar versus refined sugar? Yes! Refined sugar causes you to experience energy highs and lows and sugar cravings. Here’s why:

    Refined sugar (think candy and cakes) has no fiber to slow down its absorption, so it’s digested rapidly and enters the blood stream very quickly, causing a (blood) sugar rush/high. This sugar high, in turn, causes the body to release a surge of insulin, which quickly removes the sugar from the blood to the tissues. This is what is often known as a sugar crash or “low,” and is the body’s way of signaling that it needs a quick pick-up and the quickest pick-me-up is more sugar! This launches a vicious cycle of highs and lows that lead to a deep craving for more sugar.

    At the same time, sugary foods don’t provide the body any of the nutrients it needs to feel good and to sustain energy.

    Importantly, natural sugar provides a longer source of energy without crashes. Natural sugar comes packaged in fruit—and fruit is a good source of fiber, which slows down the digestion of glucose so you don’t get the energy high/insulin spike followed by a sugar crash like you do when you eat refined sugar. Fruit also contains water, which helps to prevent dehydration and the tired, drained feeling that comes with it that mimic blood-sugar dips.

    Here’s an important exception to the above: Fruit juice (if the fiber has been removed) will differ from fruit in the way it affects energy levels. While it still provides important nutrients that the body uses for good health, portions should be limited to prevent a blood-sugar spike and also to prevent weight gain.

    Our Bottom Line

    Overall, there is room in a wholesome, nutrient-packed diet for a small indulgence with added sugar—ideally 100 calories or less. However, the majority of people overconsume added sugars in their diet without realizing it. Truthfully, it’s beneficial for most people to make an effort to avoid added sugars because they can contribute to weight gain and take the place of other nutrient-rich foods. We suggest trying to satisfy sweet-tooth cravings with naturally sweet foods, like desserts made with fruits (as in the two recipes below). This helps people to appreciate less-sweet flavors, while also consuming added nutrients.

    One of the easiest ways to avoid added sugars is to look for them on ingredient labels. Be aware that if you purchase a sweet food and don’t see the word honey or sugar or another sweetener that you recognize on the label, this doesn’t meant there isn’t added sugar. Instead, it probably means that the sugar is hiding under a different name. The good news is that added sugars will be listed on food labels by July 2018. Until then, be mindful that added sugars in foods and drinks may be listed on labels as: anhydrous dextrose, brown sugar, cane crystals, cane sugar, corn sweetener, corn syrup, corn syrup solids, crystal dextrose, evaporated cane juice, fructose sweetener, fruit juice concentrates, high-fructose corn syrup, honey, liquid fructose, malt syrup, maple syrup, molasses, pancake syrup, raw sugar, sugar, syrup and white sugar and more.

  72. It's an interesting exercise, but it's not all about calories. You'd be a darned sight better off eating a good dose of blueberries, raspberries, apples, grapefruit or red grapes (or practically any natural fruit) daily than the equivalent amount of refined sugar cubes. It's more about processed food vs natural foods. It's always amazing to look at the contents of people's shopping trolleys, particularly the amount of white bread and fizzy drinks that people consume; highly processed, carb dense foods with NO nutritional value whatso-freakin-ever. Avoid highly refined products like flour and get a nutrient dense diet and you won't miss any of the highly-processed industrial food garbage that has increasingly found its way onto our shelves since the 19th Century.

  73. What an appalling and totally misleading presentation. The "sugar" in rice and potatoes is in the form of glucose. Glucose is needed by every cell in the body as a source of energy. Excess glucose is non toxic and is not converted into fat, which is why professional athletes carb-load before some forms of competition. The liver can store any amount of glucose with ill effect.
    The sugar in the muffin is refined sugar (the stuff of sugar cubes) that has little in common with the carbohydrate in potatoes or rice. Eating any food with added refined sugar, and these days that means 80% of food sold by the local supermarket, results in fat deposits in the liver, and is what causes heart attacks.
    If anyone really wants to understand why sugar has caused the current obesity epidemic then watch "Sugar, the bitter truth, by Dr Robert Lustig – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM&index=11&list=PL39F782316B425249&t=0s. And to make it easy, start at 45mins07seconds for an explanation of the different effects of consuming glucose, sugar, or alcohol (sugar by another name).

  74. Diabetes type 2 insulin resistance.best prevention is don’t overeat any food no matter how healthy,delicious they are.

  75. The BBC ought to be ashamed of themselves for this ridiculous bullshit. Somehow making out that brown rice and a whole jacket potato is worse than a white bagel or a chocolate muffins. And comparing everything to refined sugar as if the natural foods have the same effect on the body. Arseholes. "Carbs are bad m'kay"

  76. Actually I am not very surprised. I have for about one year without putting in my mouth starchy foods, especially bread. And idk why people tend to eat heavy foods just to make them feel full without worrying about the consequences of that.

  77. Officially lost respect for BBC. Very misleading.

  78. So the only food we can eat are meat and vegetables with fruits as a treat? This is the take home message from this video? Absololute nonsense! We need food for energy, over 2000 calories of it! The food in this video are eccellent sources of Energy!

  79. But the strawberries have more fructose sugar which is not the same as table sugar (sucrose). Although sucrose is made out of fructose and glucose. Plus your body would process the fructose differently because of the fibre in the fruit.

  80. what rubbish! rice potatoes evil ????

  81. absolute bullshit "Hilarious"

  82. comparing carbs to foods as carbs in sugar

  83. For some reason I am not shocked.

  84. dude, the suger in white rice doesn't make sense… UK u dnt know what you talking about.

  85. Whst more sugar in a bagel than a muffin seriously??

  86. This is a load of carp!
    Walter Kempner reversed diabetes 2 with, rice, fruits and refined sugar in the 40ies.
    And Andrew Tailor lost 50kg on an all potato diet for a year. Links below;

    https://www.drmcdougall.com/2013/12/31/walter-kempner-md-founder-of-the-rice-diet/

    https://www.google.dk/amp/s/amp.news.com.au/lifestyle/health/diet/andrew-taylor-eats-nothing-but-potatoes-for-a-year-to-cure-his-food-addiction/news-story/41d8e6612679985fc9bf62e4b970ef15

  87. Too bad these folks in this video are spreading disinformation. So sad

  88. this is why our country has a high rate of diabetes (Philippines)

  89. So let's all just eat sand.

  90. Omg woah it's very shocking

  91. This video is spreading complete bullshit.

  92. stop eating daughnuts and muffins, pancake icecream

  93. The dietary sugar is not the same as serum glucose. They're worlds apart. You can't talk about equivalence because the way sugar (Sucrose) is metabolised and the way starch is metabolised are worlds apart. The fructose portion of sugar is mostly metabolised in the liver. The glucose from starch can be used by virtually all the cells of the body.

    Nutritional science here at its worst.

  94. This is so misleading.You cannot compare refined sugar to natural sugars contained in whole foods. Carbohydrates are what humans are designed to eat for energy. I'm not talking about refined carbs but whole food carbs. Starches.

  95. This is stupid , strawberries will be differently processed to a cup cake lol

  96. Nothing misleading about this …. eating too many carbs, whether refined or complex, stimulates insulin production and, consequently, fat storage.

Comment here